I gave these 5 stars since the reason I had to return was my fault.....my size (9w) was out of stock so I tried a 9m. It was too narrow for my foot. I love the soft, tooled leather and the look of the shoe but I missed out.This is my second pair of the Caledonia sneakers by Comfortivia. The first day I wear them they don't give blisters and feel very cushioney and comfortable! I am so glad I found this brand. I wil definitely by again and always.Love the color and the fit. Have not worn them anywhere yet. They were comfortable when I tried them on when received. Have other Comfortiva shoes and like them.I have had several pairs of these shoes and like them very much.Casual DressI love these shoes! Very comfy! I waitressed in them all night with no problems. They are super cute too!I have feet problems,I have to have comfy shoes. I bought this brand in boots last year and now these I love both, these are great shoes for everyday!I love the shoes great support great looking I get good Comments all the time